Tuesday, October 28, 2014

Literary Criticism Analysis

     In George M. Spangler's "The Ending of The Novel", he describes the inconsistencies of Edna's character at the end of The Awakening.  For example, Spangler writes, "It's great fault is inconstant characterization, which asks the reader to accept a different and diminished Edna from the one developed so impressively before".  I agree with this because Chopin makes the reader believe that Edna will have a romantic ending and that Edna will continue being independent.  I think the final moments of Edna ending her life is to shock the reader rather than continue with the themes.  It is very startling to the reader how Edna acts on her impulse and doesn't think before she makes decisions.  Maybe if she had thought about her first initiative of drowning herself, she wouldn't have done it.  I feel as almost as if she doesn't have common sense.  Maybe if she was more attentive to her thoughts, she would make better decisions.  Spangler also states, "And the painful failure of vision...implicit in the change prevents a very good, very interesting novel from being the extraordinary masterpiece some commentators have claimed it is".  I think if Chopin had made Edna successful in the women's rights campaign, then people wouldn't read the book.  People wouldn't be as intrigued by it if it was a basic happy ending.  The book is so rebellious and different for its time, just as Edna was.  In a way Chopin is Edna.  Edna had very strong opinions at first and was very confident.  But then she gave up so easily in the last second.  Chopin wrote this novel without even thinking what other people may think.  However when people started criticizing her, she admitted to faults in her writing.  Overall, I agree with Spangler's writing because it really portrays the way the readers view Edna.        

No comments:

Post a Comment