Tuesday, October 28, 2014

Literary Criticism Analysis

     In George M. Spangler's "The Ending of The Novel", he describes the inconsistencies of Edna's character at the end of The Awakening.  For example, Spangler writes, "It's great fault is inconstant characterization, which asks the reader to accept a different and diminished Edna from the one developed so impressively before".  I agree with this because Chopin makes the reader believe that Edna will have a romantic ending and that Edna will continue being independent.  I think the final moments of Edna ending her life is to shock the reader rather than continue with the themes.  It is very startling to the reader how Edna acts on her impulse and doesn't think before she makes decisions.  Maybe if she had thought about her first initiative of drowning herself, she wouldn't have done it.  I feel as almost as if she doesn't have common sense.  Maybe if she was more attentive to her thoughts, she would make better decisions.  Spangler also states, "And the painful failure of vision...implicit in the change prevents a very good, very interesting novel from being the extraordinary masterpiece some commentators have claimed it is".  I think if Chopin had made Edna successful in the women's rights campaign, then people wouldn't read the book.  People wouldn't be as intrigued by it if it was a basic happy ending.  The book is so rebellious and different for its time, just as Edna was.  In a way Chopin is Edna.  Edna had very strong opinions at first and was very confident.  But then she gave up so easily in the last second.  Chopin wrote this novel without even thinking what other people may think.  However when people started criticizing her, she admitted to faults in her writing.  Overall, I agree with Spangler's writing because it really portrays the way the readers view Edna.        

Sunday, October 26, 2014

"The Awakening" chapters 31-39 DJs


  • "So he had come back because the Mexicans were not congenial; because business was as profitable here as there; because of any reason, and not because he cared to be near her" (Chopin 132).  
This is talking about how when Robert came back, his return was not how Edna was expecting it to be.  Maybe this was her revenge for defying society and going against the common stereotypes.  Or maybe it was because Robert did not want to admit he loved Edna.  This relates to the theme of the novel that loneliness is almost like a consequence for independence.  Robert does not act as Edna wants him too.  Arobin is the only person who acts as he loves her, but Edna finds out he treats every woman he meets the same way as he's treating Edna.  So Edna feels alone.  At first she loved having the freedom, but Robert's note of saying "I love you.  Good-by, because I love you" only empahsizes how there is a consequence for lying.  Leonce doesn't know that Edna's cheating on him and that only backfired on her with Roberts first reaction to seeing her.

  • "'The trouble is' sighed the doctor, grasping her meaning intuitively, 'that youth is given up to illusions.  It seems to be a provision of Nature; a decoy to secure mothers for the race'" (Chopin 151).  
This illustrates how society doesn't accept change.  When the doctor is saying this, he is basically stating that women should be sucured as mothers, that the youth is all about wanting a better life.  When in reality, the doctor thinks the youth is full of ideas that don't make sense.  I think he is trying to convince Edna that change is not a good thing to want.   He thinks independence for women is just another vision, it shouldn't actually happen - that's why he tells her she's willing to him whenever she pleases.  Even though that may seem genuine and kind, it also shows his way of seeing how Edna is going to act in regards to wanting this different life.

  • "The foamy wavelets curled up to her white feet, and coiled like serpents about her ankles" (Chopin 156).  
This goes back to the ocean representing freedom that appeared at the beginning of the novel.  It emphasizes the theme that women should be aloud to have rights and should be able to think on their own.  The waves around Edna's feet can symbolize the feeling of independence taking over her mind. She is realizing she doesn't need Robert, or Alcee, or Leonce.  All she needs is herself.  She realizes she needs to be alone sometimes.  She doesn't need to rely on someone else.

Thursday, October 23, 2014

"The Awakening" chapters 22-30 DJs


  • "'Are you in love with Robert?' 'Yes,' said Edna.  It was the first time she had admitted it, and a glow overspread her face, blotching it with red spots" (Chopin 110).
Edna has changed so much that she now openly admits she loves Robert.  This contributes to "The Awakening" as a whole because Edna's personality is changing.  She is becoming rebellious and taking her husbands leave as an advantage to her rebellion.  She is finding out whom she really is.  She realizes she is not the typical housewife and Robert respects that of her.  Mlle. Reisz says the reason why Robert is writing the letters to her and not Edna is because he wants to forget about her, since he is in love with her.  This changes Edna's whole view on Robert.  She now wants to be with him.

  • "When he leaned forward and kissed her, she clasped his head, holding hid lips to hers.  It was the first kiss of her life to which her nature had really responded" (Chopin 112).  
Maybe Edna is using Arobin as a way to not think about Robert.  Or maybe she is actually in love with Arobin, she might just be infatuated with Robert.  This illustrates Edna's rebellion taking place. She cheated on Leonce.  He doesn't have any idea of what Edna's doing, so she's using that excuse as an advantage.  This is probably why Edna is moving out of her house, she might want to be able to be with Arobin.    

  • "She was mounted upon a high stepladder, unhooking a picture from the wall when he entered" (Chopin 114).   
This ladder could symbolize Edna rising up in society because the ladder is rising up.  It could represent Edna gaining more power.  The ladder being so tall could also represent Edna's external height.  She is described as broad and tall.  It can symbolize her growth internally as well.  This growth relates to "The Awakening" as a whole because she is rising, or wants to rise about her husband.  She doesn't want to be treated as just another wife/ mother.    

Tuesday, October 21, 2014

"The Awakening" chapters 11-21 DJs


  • "The past was nothing to her;...The future was a mystery which she never attempted to penetrate.  The present alone was significant; was hers, to torture her..." (Chopin 61).  
This quote summarizes Edna's life.  She doesn't think about the future, she doesn't even consider thinking about her past in a positive way, the present is most important to her.  She only obsesses about her infatuation with Robert.  
  • "To succeed, the artist must possess the courageous soul" (Chopin 85).  
I'm confused by this quote.  Does this mean an artist has to be brave and defy society with their work?  Is that what Edna's doing?  
  • "Robert's letter was on the floor...It was crumbled and damp with tears" (Chopin 87).  
This can foreshadow that Edna will fall in love with Robert.  I think Robert will return just for Edna.  But Edna is being overly emotional with the fact that she is already married.  Maybe because of this letter she will start defying society - I'm confused with this quote as well.    

Monday, October 20, 2014

"The Awakening" chapters 1-10 DJs


  • "A green and yellow parrot , which hung in a cage outside the door, kept repeating over and over: 'Allez vous-en!'" (Chopin 1).  
As I read further into the story, I realized the parrot symbolizes the relationship between Mr. and Mrs. Pontellier.  The parrot is described as annoying and repetitive.  It sort of reminded me of their relationship because neither Mr. or Mrs. Pontellier change their views, which is repetitive just like the parrot.     
  • "'You are burnt beyond recognition,' he added, looking at his wife as one looks at a valuable piece of personal property which has suffered some damage" (Chopin 3).    
This shows that Mr. Pontellier does not treat his wife with respect.  Why would they compare Mrs. Pontellier to property?  She's a person, she is not owned by anyone, but that's how Mr. Pontellier makes it seem.  

  • "'How easy it is!'" she thought.  'It is nothing' she said aloud;...she swam out alone" (Chopin 37). 
   This shows how Mrs. Pontellier found a new freedom.  She was swimming, almost as if she was swimming to get away from her husband.  Her realizing she could swim really gave her a new opportunity.  She could have the power to go where she wants without the opposition of her husband.  

Friday, October 3, 2014

"Happy Endings"

Sentence - Sentence Structure/ Style

"He comes to her apartment twice a week and she cooks him dinner...the reverse order form the one in which he took them off" - long and involved sentence

"John and Mary fall in love and get married" - Declarative sentence

"Mary falls in love with John but John doesn't fall in love with Mary" - Compound Sentence

"So much for endings.  Beginnings are always more fun" - Subjective

"John and Mary die.  John and Mary dies.  John and Mary die" - Repetition 

"Everything becomes very underwater" - Metaphor

"One day James breezes in on his motorcycle with some top-grade California hybrid and James and Mary get higher and higher than you believe possible and they climb into bed" - Periodic Sentence 


Wednesday, October 1, 2014

"The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas" literary analysis

In the short story The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas, Ursula Le Guin uses symbolism and setting to say that people in this world are greedy - that their happiness only comes from others misery.

Guin uses symbolism in this story.  For example, the child who has been locked in a dark room for all of his or her life represents the how people do not think of others besides themselves.  The people of Omelas would rather be happy all the time than help a miserable and scared child.  They do not put others before themselves.

Guin describes the setting in this story with great detail.  In the first paragraph, it is stated that "In the streets between houses with red roofs and painted walls, between old moss-grown gardens and under avenues of trees, past great parks and public buildings, processions moved".  This emphasizes how much the people are concerned with just where they live, and nobody else's feelings but themselves.

Symbolism and setting contribute to the overall meaning of the story that happiness should not be dependent on others' misery.